The Dump – April 25, 2025
Originally posted April 25, 2025
It’s been a week. From fake firms in federal court to high drama at the school board mic, Williamson County reminded us that dignity is optional—but public comment is forever.
Imaginary consultants. Ninety-second monologues. Subpoenas with a side of selective amnesia.
Let’s dump it out.
⸻
ENVELOPES AND EGO: FAKE MEN, REAL MONEY, LESS DIGNITY
What do you get when you mix 20 counts of federal fraud, a fake alias named Matthew Phoenix, a defunct speaker, and enough shady contracts to make Enron blush?
Welcome to The State of Tennessee v. Glen Casada and Cade Cothren, opening this week in a courtroom near you—where witnesses wear suits (and wires), reputations go to die, and everyone’s praying their name isn’t in the indictment index.
THE CHARGES
Casada and Cothren are facing a federal legal beatdown for allegedly creating a fake political mailer company—Phoenix Solutions—to funnel taxpayer money to themselves under the table.
Cothren allegedly ran the show using an alias. Yes, really. Because nothing says “innocent” like billing the government using a name that sounds like an adult film star.
Meanwhile, the defense is floating a bold strategy: fraud isn’t fraud—it’s just a business model.
Casada’s attorney, Ed Yarbrough, began jury selection by asking potential alternates if they’ve ever received commissions, worked in sales, or outsourced projects.
“Did your customers always know who was doing the work?” Yarbrough asked, implying that deception might be standard practice in the free market.
The message? Maybe a kickback is just capitalism with extra steps.
Federal prosecutors aren’t buying it. They say Casada and former Rep. Robin Smith pressured GOP lawmakers to use Phoenix Solutions while actively hiding Cothren’s identity—knowing his reputation would sink any deal.
Cothren used a burner Gmail and the alias “Matthew Phoenix” to set it all up. Casada played dumb. State money flowed. And now? Federal court gets to untangle the fallout.
MEET THE PLAYERS
• Glen Casada – Former House speaker. Current defendant. Once the guy with the gavel, now the guy muttering “I don’t recall.”
• Cade Cothren – Political bro turned federal defendant. Known for racist texts, bathroom cocaine, and inventing imaginary friends for money.
• Matthew Phoenix – Not a real person. Just Cothren (cough… allegedly). The guy never existed, but the invoices sure did.
• Rep. Cameron Sexton – Current speaker. Subpoenaed. Rumors say he spoke to the FBI long ago. He’s not saying much—and that says everything.
• Robin Smith – Former rep. Pleaded guilty. Will testify. Probably rehearsing a tearful regret face in the mirror right now, just in case Netflix is casting.
• Rep. Todd Warner – Still doing business with Cothren’s other sketchy “firm.” Told the press: “A hit job by our own folks.” So the issue is party infighting—not the actual fraud? Got it.
• William Lamberth – House majority leader. Subpoenaed. May have known something. May have known nothing. Nobody knows.
• Michael Lotfi – Cashed six figures from Casada’s PACs. Landed quietly on the state payroll. Job title: unclear. Ethics: unavailable.
• Holt Whitt – Sexton’s ex-chief of staff. Conveniently “on leave” after the FBI came knocking. Will testify. Didn’t plan to be in this segment.
Let’s hear it for the contestants! May the odds forever be in your favor.
To recap the alleged scheme, Cothren cashed the checks. Casada played dumb. Everyone else shrugged. It wasn’t slick. It wasn’t smart. It was just Tennessee-style grift.
And now? The courthouse is filling with current and former officials who looked the other way, signed the checks, or just assumed nobody would notice a ghost consultant named Matt Phoenix. (Really, guys?)
WW BOTTOM LINE
The Phoenix may have risen… But it’s crashing like a mailer no one opens.
More to come.
⸻
THE SCHOOL BOARD MEETING WAS FINE. BUT LET’S TALK ABOUT THE PUBLIC COMMENTS.
The April 21 WCS Board meeting came and went. The vote was already done. The agenda moved along.
And the fireworks? Right on cue—seventeen speakers deep, scripts in hand, each prepped for their three-minute TED Talk… until they found out the mic was only open for ninety seconds. Panic ensued.
Front row, dead center: One Willco’s Cory Martin. Black shirt. Dark demure. The solemn energy of a man live-blogging a funeral. His presence alone could trigger a records request.
Cory, maybe mix in a pastel next time. You’re not leading a resistance cell—you’re at a school board meeting. In spring.
Then came the opener—Angela Frederick, president of the Williamson County Education Association (WCEA). She approached the podium like she was leading a candlelight vigil and offered:
“We don’t wish for there to be animosity between teachers and school board members. We have the same goal in mind, which is student success…”
A lovely sentiment… if it hadn’t come from someone who just spent a month treating the board’s science textbook vote like they replaced it with Flat Earth scrolls.
She knew the board asked for more information. She wasn’t blindsided. She just picked outrage over honesty when the vote didn’t go her way.
So now when she pleads for unity, it feels a little like arsonists asking for marshmallows.
But credit where it’s due—she finally said something everyone can agree on.
⸻
And then came the Williamson Strong–One Willco Players, debuting their latest production:
“You’re Not a Teacher, So You Don’t Count: A Tragedy in Ninety-Second Intervals.”
Backed by party operatives and powered by oat milk and moral outrage, the cast delivered monologues like they were auditioning for the saddest little podcast in town—hosted by Nancy Garrett and Jennifer Aprea, who still list “former school board member” like it’s a hereditary title.
The tone? Charged.
The message? Mixed.
• One speaker led off: “86% of emails opposed the board’s decision.”—Awesome. We’re governing by inbox… again.
• Another speaker delivered a psychological breakdown of student mental health, citing LGBTQ+ stressors, seemingly under the belief that textbook concerns equals identity denial.—Spoiler: they don’t.
• A parent cited 2,363 WCS teachers and quoted the board’s own mission back at them.—Delivery: passive-aggressive. Impact: meh.
• And then, of course: a speaker hinted at financial impropriety—because a board member didn’t sign the same oath as the textbook committee.—That’s not corruption. That’s called… disagreement. Exit stage left.
⸻
Not to be outdone, a lone Moms for Liberty speaker took the mic in her MFL tee and backed the board. The crowd wasn’t with her—but she stood tall and made her case. That takes spine.
She invoked the “silent majority”—a line that gets eye rolls from activists.
But here’s the inconvenient truth: emails aren’t votes. Stickers aren’t elections. Lawn signs don’t count ballots.
Votes happened. The board reflects that.
That’s not a glitch in the matrix. That’s democracy.
⸻
And finally: a special thanks to Democratic Party Chair Peggy Kingsbury, who made good on her sticker promise. (Former chair, we’re told. Check the comments.)
But… a yellow sticky note no one could read? That’s the best you could do?
C’mon, Peggy. At least give us a school bus. Or a ruler. Something.
We’re giving it a Dull-minus from the graphic design department. Maybe Cory Martin can stop FOIAing the water fountains and whip up a logo. He’s literally sitting right next to you… staring into the abyss.
⸻
WW BOTTOM LINE
This wasn’t about reversing a decision. It was about staging a moment.
The mic’s not a time machine. The toothpaste isn’t going back in the tube. And no sticker will issue a stop payment.
So here’s a wild idea: set down the bullhorn, grab a highlighter, watch the training video… and teach the kids.
Time to look ahead.
⸻
BRENTWOOD BALLOT WATCH: EARLY VOTING NOW UNDERWAY
Early voting in Brentwood’s city commission election is officially open and runs through May 1. Election Day is Tuesday, May 6.
After months of ethics complaints, chamber drama, and political therapy sessions disguised as meetings—it’s finally your turn at the mic.
WW BOTTOM LINE
Vote low drama. You deserve a city commission that doesn’t need a PR firm and a well deserved timeout.
⸻
BUNS OF GLORY: WHATABURGER ARRIVES, BRENTWOOD POLICE RESPOND WITH SQUATS
In Brentwood, it’s shaping up to be a battle of lifestyle choices: greasy satisfaction or gas-masked repentance. Choose your fighter.
First up: the culinary invasion.
The orange-and-white titan of Texas is rolling into Brentwood like a spiced-up cavalry charge with extra jalapeños. Whataburger has officially slapped its logo on the old Back Yard Burgers building at 5004 Maryland Way, and come May 12 at 11:00 a.m., it’s game on for Williamson County's arteries.
This marks the chain’s first official invasion of Williamson County, forcing local burger joints to prepare for incoming fire in the form of honey butter chicken biscuits, spicy ketchup, and nostalgic Texans swearing it's better than Five Guys.
Construction is nearly finished, signage is up, and according to Whataburger reps, the grills will be hot and the fries will be crispy in just a few weeks.
Until now, Williamson County diehards had to trek to Antioch or Smyrna to get their fix—which, let’s be honest, is a big commitment unless you’re also picking up a catalytic converter.
The burger wars may be heating up—but let’s face it: nothing beats a taquito.
And now, in a move that’s either poetic timing or strategic damage control…
________________________________________
BURPEES & BAD DECISIONS: BRENTWOOD PD HOSTS PAIN-BASED TEAM BUILDING
The Brentwood Police Department would like to invite you—and your overconfident gym buddy—to this year’s TAC Team Challenge on Saturday, May 3rd.
Think CrossFit, if CrossFit worked the graveyard shift, wore a gas mask, and lifted retired Civil War cannonballs.
Here’s a quick rundown of the five events—part workout, part evidence in your future injury claim:
1. 800m Run—Minimum: 4 minutes, 29 seconds. Translation: Run like your ex just pulled into the parking lot.
2. 400m Run with Dumbbells and Gas Mask—Carry 225-pound dumbbells while wheezing through a glorified Halloween costume.
3. Burpees – 3 Minutes—38 gets you 2 points. Any more, and you earn the right to judge others at Carbon Performance.
4. Air Squats – 2 Minutes—Required: 64. Gear: Gas mask and vest.
Optional: A will to live.
5. Pull-Ups – 1 Minute—First 5 must be strict. Kipping? No. Flailing like a muppet? Also no. If you can crank out 12, you are officially in better shape than 98% of Brentwood.
Still think you’ve got what it takes? A few spots are left, so sign up—before your knees or common sense talk you out of it.
Event Date: Saturday, May 3rd
Location: Brentwood Police Department
Bring: Bring grit. Bring water. And maybe double-check your deductible.
________________________________________
FINAL FLUSH: REWIND, REPEAT, REALITY
Let’s rewind to 2021.
In Williamson County, book policies sparked a firestorm. Parents lined up. Lawsuits loomed. Livestreams mysteriously cut off. The school board got hammered from both sides. Emotions boiled.
That’s when we realized: something’s broken.
Fast-forward to 2025—same chapter, slightly edited footnote.
A 2024 lawsuit accused the board of ignoring the Age-Appropriate Materials Act. A judge agreed. On Monday night, the board passed Policy 4.403 on second reading, 9–3.
The only change? One verb.
“Should any portion of this section (a–g) be held to be unconstitutional or unenforceable… that portion shall be deemed to be removed… without the necessity of further action by the Board.”
Yes, there’s now an exit clause. If a judge strikes the law, that part of the policy disappears quietly—without triggering another drama cycle. Smart. Responsible. Budget-friendly.
WCS isn’t banning books. It’s navigating lawsuits and legislation while trying to keep the focus on classrooms—not courtrooms.
⸻
DOWN THE ROAD: BOOK BONFIRE SEASON BEGINS
Meanwhile, in Rutherford County:
Over 145 books removed—many using a third-party site tied to Moms for Liberty. Librarians weren’t consulted. No nuance. Just a digital purge.
The ACLU and PEN America sued on April 16, citing political censorship and overreach.
“Defendants removed books… because they disagree with the ideas or views contained in those books.”
— ACLU/PEN Complaint, 4/16/25
In 70% of cases, the board overruled its own library experts. Because nothing says “we value professionalism” like ignoring it completely.
⸻
Here in Williamson?
We’re doing it differently—because some folks actually did the work.
Board member Claire Reeves read all five contested books. She reviewed the law. She listened. And then she proposed something that wasn’t a culture war: a mature materials list.
Not a ban.
Not a blacklist.
An opt-in.
“The current opt-out process is flawed… Librarians aren’t expected to read every book, but we expect parents to? That’s backward.”
— Claire Reeves
It’s practical. It’s fair. And it just might lower everyone’s blood pressure.
⸻
WHAT NOW?
We won’t codify our way to perfect harmony. A book you love might not be on the shelf. A book you hate probably will be.
But parental engagement? Still undefeated.
Know the teachers. Know the books. Talk to your librarian. And maybe, just maybe—listen more than you criticize.
Because in a world where every disagreement is “a slap in the face,” most families are just trying to breathe.
This policy isn’t perfect. But it’s a step toward something better: Clarity. Trust. Civility.
We don’t have to agree on every book.
But we can agree on this: we want to raise kids who think critically, live honorably, and grow up in a community that knows how to disagree—without bringing a matchbox to every debate.
What if the real legacy isn’t what we banned or didn't—but how we chose not to burn everything down?
⸻
That’s it for this week, friends. And if we miscounted the number of burner accounts or angry emails, please forward all complaints to Matthew Phoenix.
See you next week.
—WW